Nantucket in the summer is a dream, but did you know that the magic doesn’t end with August? September on the island is often referred to as “second summer,” and for good reason. It is warmer in the fall than the mainland because of the surrounding ocean, which warms up throughout the summer and keeps the island’s weather mild into the fall. With these milder temperatures, smaller crowds, and a host of unique experiences, this is the perfect time to discover the true charm of Nantucket.
Why “Second Summer” is the Best Time to Visit Nantucket
Perfect Weather Without the Crowds: September brings milder temperatures, with average highs in the 70s, making it ideal for enjoying the island’s natural beauty. The ocean is still warm from the summer sun, perfect for swimming, sailing, or simply relaxing on the beach. Best of all, the crowds have thinned, giving you more space to explore and unwind.
Unique Events and Activities: Nantucket’s social calendar doesn’t slow down in September. From art festivals to wine tastings and cultural celebrations, there’s always something to enjoy. Attend events like the Nantucket Island Fair, celebrating the island’s rich agricultural history, or the Nantucket Project, a gathering of creative thinkers and leaders. September also sees the continuation of weekly farmers’ markets, art exhibitions, and live music, ensuring there’s always something to do.
Stunning Natural Scenery: The natural beauty of Nantucket is on full display in September. The island’s famous cranberry bogs begin to blush, and the heather-covered moors are a sight to behold. Explore the extensive network of biking and hiking trails, visit popular lighthouses like Brant Point of Sankaty Light, or take a stroll along the shorelines, go whale watching, stroll the famous Sconset Bluff Walk, or simply relax on the pristine beaches.
A Culinary Delight: September is a fantastic time to savor Nantucket’s renowned culinary scene. With fewer tourists, you can easily grab a table at the island’s popular restaurants like Brotherhood of Thieves, or stand in a much shorter line in at The Lemon Press, an organic cafe. Many eateries feature farm-to-table menus, highlighting the freshest local ingredients, including seafood and seasonal produce. Don’t miss the famous Nantucket oysters or a classic lobster roll.
A Relaxed Island Atmosphere: The pace of life on Nantucket slows down in September, offering a more relaxed and authentic island experience. Whether you’re shopping in the quaint boutiques on the cobblestoned streets of downtown Nantucket, exploring the island's historical sites like the Nantucket Whaling Museum, or simply enjoying the serenity of your vacation rental, you’ll find a calm that’s harder to come by during the busy summer.
Convenient Accessibility: With the summer rush over, getting to and from Nantucket becomes more convenient and less stressful. Ferries and flights are still running frequently, but without the long lines and waits. Plus, the cooler weather makes the journey even more pleasant.
Affordable Luxury: With the peak summer season behind us, September offers more affordable rates on vacation rentals. This is the time to take advantage of discounts on luxurious accommodations that may have been out of reach during the summer. Whether you’re looking for a cozy cottage or a spacious beachfront home, you’re likely to find the perfect place at a more budget-friendly price on WeNeedaVacation.com. And when you book through WeNeedaVacation you save even more money, because we don’t charge booking fees!
Nantucket’s “Second Summer” in September is the perfect blend of warm weather, fewer crowds, and a peaceful atmosphere. Whether you’re looking for a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a solo retreat, this idyllic island offers an unparalleled experience during this time of year. Book your stay with us on Cape Cod and make Nantucket your September escape—you won’t be disappointed.